Two people shaking hands

12 Critical Tips To Ensure Authenticity In Marketing

Published

3 min. read

Relevant Solutions

The Pollack Group’s proprietary solutions combine decades of communications experience with specialized methodologies, technology and audience intelligence to help organizations solve specific business and reputation challenges.

Today’s consumers are well-aware of inauthentic marketing when we see it. If a brand wants to truly connect with its customers, it needs to find ways to resonate authentically. The agency was featured in the Forbes Agency Council’s latest piece, ‘How to Ensure Authenticity in Marketing: 12 Critical Tips.’ View the original article on Forbes. The No. 2 contribution is from agency president Stefan Pollack.‍

2. Understand Your Brand Promise

Businesses should first of all understand their brand promise. What is it that their consumers expect of them? What is their core philosophy? What is the brand’s DNA — not its ideal, but the truth of its culture and impact? Once that is known, any message that strays from that brand promise will be inauthentic. – Stefan Pollack, The Pollack Group

—

1. Make Your Customer The Superhero

If you make your product or people the superhero, you’re putting your brand above your customer and looking down at them. This positioning makes you appear inauthentic and untrustworthy. In your marketing, the superhero is always your customer. Your product or service is the tool that enables them to achieve the superior results they’re seeking. – Douglas Karr, Highbridge

2. See Above

3. Project What Your Brand Stands For

Every clever marketing campaign should project the heart of the brand and what it stands for. All marketing projects must be consistent in messaging to truly connect with the consumer and showcase the values of the brand, ensuring authenticity. – Jessica Hawthorne-Castro, Hawthorne LLC

4. Develop A Brand Style Guide Early On

Branding is storytelling, and authenticity and consistency are key. Developing a brand bible and style guide early is a helpful tool to crystallize your story. You should include elements like positioning, mission, pillars, dos/don’ts, visual identity, etc. These will serve as a North Star internally and will also enable partners, agencies and other extensions of your team to know your story. – Marc Becker, The Tangent Agency

5. Gather As Much Feedback As Possible

What you think customers want and what customers actually want are not always the same. Gather as much customer feedback and engagement metrics as possible to learn how they talk about your product/service and what they want or need from it. Use that information to build a marketing strategy and you will be sure to resonate with your target audience in an authentic way. – Donna Robinson, Collective Measures

6. Focus On Providing Value And Educating

The single best way to have authentic marketing is to give value first. Instead of always trying to sell, sell, sell, make sure you take the time to educate. We pride ourselves on our blog, training and learning hub. We give access to all of them for free because we believe in value first. If we can get our customers to trust us, then the selling will come even easier later in the funnel. – Marc Hardgrove, The HOTH

7. Feature Your Subject-Matter Experts

People trust people, not brands. It’s important to look for ways to feature the subject-matter experts behind your company because it’s easier for someone to connect with a person than a brand. People want to buy from people they trust, and learning about your founders’ stories, values and experience can help build that trust. – Kelsey Raymond, Influence & Co.

8. Have A Story With A Human Touch

Make sure your brand has a story with a human touch. Showing why customers need your product or service is not enough, you have to connect with them on a deeper level — and that’s where storytelling comes in. What’s the story behind the brand? Why does it exist? When your brand has a proper story behind it, you’ll win the loyalty of consumers and that’s priceless. – Randy Soderman, Soderman SEO

9. Focus On Product Benefits, Not Features

Authentic marketing always focuses on product benefits, not product features. To ensure authenticity, first understand how your product makes the customer’s life better, easier or more enjoyable; i.e., the product benefits. Then ensure that marketing content focuses on telling that product benefit story. This approach helps your marketing content resonate and keeps it authentic. – Aliza Freud, SheSpeaks, Inc.

10. Keep Your Message And Tone Consistent

Keep your message and tone consistent. If you’re clever, be clever. If you’re snarky, be snarky. It’s the inconsistency of this tone that can sound fake. If the written content on your site is a bit casual and loose, but the videos on your site are overly “corporate,” your brand will reek of inauthenticity. Clever and catchy are OK, but don’t do it halfway. – Bernard May, National Positions

11. Always Test Before Launch

Even the best creative can have a blind spot, so it’s critical to test before launch. Test it! Too often, campaigns come out without input from a variety of demographics. If you want to be authentic, you must first test it with your internal team and collect feedback based on how it makes them feel and how they expect the outside world will react. – Kathleen Lucente, Red Fan Communications

12. Don’t Be Afraid To Be Vulnerable

Be vulnerable. Nobody’s perfect, so if your marketing suggests that you are, it will always come off as inauthentic. I saw a restaurant that advertised that its rooftop bar was “well worth the three flights of stairs.” That’s clever and self-deprecating in a way that resonates with consumers. – Scott Baradell, Idea Grove

The Latest

Stefan Pollack, President and CFO of The Pollack Group, has been named a 2026 Inspiring Leader by the Inspiring Workplaces Group

| Red All About It

Stefan Pollack Recognized as a 2026 Inspiring Leader for Second Consecutive Year

Stefan Pollack earns his second consecutive Inspiring Leader recognition in 2026 for his commitment to people-first leadership, mentorship and workplace culture

Designers brainstorming and collaborating on creative campaigns, supporting branding and digital marketing initiatives

| In The Red

How to Choose a PR and Creative Agency for Brand Storytelling

What to expect from an agency that combines PR and creative, the evidence to request, a scored checklist and a shortlist template for brand managers.

PR and marketing experts at The Pollack Group share their predictions on AI search visibility, brand reputation management, and communications trends.

| In The Red

Looking Ahead to 2027: Our Predictions for PR and Marketing

What's ahead for PR and marketing in 2027? The Pollack Group shares predictions on AI search, brand reputation, discoverability and communications trends.

Public relations professionals develop communications and media relations strategies for brands to connect with their target audiences and foster lasting relationships with the media.

| In The Red

How to Choose a PR and Marketing Agency for Your Industry: A Buyer’s Guide

How to choose a PR agency for crisis, nonprofit, B2B tech, fintech, consumer, food and beverage or startup needs: criteria, proof and pitch questions.